Going by the MAL score averages and don't include continuations the AOTS was Non Non Biyori Repeat (8.33) followed in a close second by Junjou Romantica 3 (8.27)...

Tied for third were Working (S3) and Prison School with 8.22This makes Prison School the highest rated non-sequel series to come from this season.Despite Winning a poll on this subreddit Shimoneta didn't even place top 10.If you include continuations from previous seasons then Gintama is still on top, Shokugeki for 2nd and One Piece for third.The Lowest Three were Million Doll (5.01), Makura no Danshi (5.34) and Bikini Warriors (5.46)The step-three average of the season (that's where you calculate the average using only every third result) was 7.11Charlotte has the most members (that does include completes+drops+on-holds+PTWs).Interestingly the "Top 3" scoring title with the most members is Prison School, with the 7th most members.The "AOTS" Non Non Biyori Repeat has the 25th most membersFor anyone who didn't know (e.g. me) Junjou Romantica is some kind of Yaoi comedy/drama. It had the 31st most members.Link here for anyone interested in doing there own snooping http://ift.tt/1VuhvSY